Mortality after
Cardiac Surgery with or without Microwave Ablation in Patients with Permanent
Atrial Fibrillation
Michael Knaut, Sems M. Tugtekin, Stefan Spitzer, Friedrich
Jung, Klaus Matschke
Department of Cardiac Surgery, University of Technology
Dresden, Dresden, Praxisklinnik Herz-und Gefäße, Institute
for Heart and Circulation Research, Hoyerswerda, Germany |
Background and aim of the study: The surgical
treatment of atrial fibrillation (AF) by Cox and other ablation methods
shows a 50-90% conversion rate to sinus rhythm. However, to date no study
has addressed the influence of ablation on the mortality rate.
Methods: The perioperative and postoperative mortalities
of 210 consecutive patients with permanent AF was investigated
for up to two years after cardiac surgery with (n = 111) or without
(n = 99) endocardial microwave ablation within the framework of
a prospective register study. All patients were followed up.
Results: In the ablation group, one patient (0.9%) died
perioperatively, seven died during the first year of follow up
(6.3%), and nine in the second year of follow up (8.1%). In the
control group, five patients died |
perioperatively (5.1%), 12 died in the first year of follow
up (12.1%), and 22 in the second year of follow up (22.2%). During the
two-year follow up period, significantly more patients died in the control
group than in the ablation group (Log-Rank test: p = 0.0051).
Conclusion: The results of this register study showed
that among patients with permanent AF who underwent cardiac surgery
with ablation, mortality was significantly lower than in those
who underwent comparable surgery but without ablation. The marked
difference in mortality was essentially based on the typical clinical
consequences of AF (e.g. thromboembolic complications, cardiac
arrhythmias and bleeding complications due to anticoagulation therapy),
which occurred less often in the ablation group.
The Journal of Heart Valve Disease 2005;14:531-537 |