The modified Duromedics-Tekna bileaflet pyrolitic carbon mechanical prosthesis was reintroduced by Baxter in 1990. This report details the first case of sudden leaflet fracture of a Tekna mitral valve five years after implantation, which was managed successfully by replacement with a St. Jude Medical mechanical prosthesis. The fracture had occurred transversely, with the fragments embolizing to the terminal aortic bifurcation and the left common femoral artery. These were localized by a computed tomography and removed two days after valve replacement.